In 1968, Edward Altman, then a lecturer at New York University, compared 33 bankrupt companies with 33 healthy ones and looked for the ratios that made the difference. His formula, the Z-score, is still used by banks and credit analysts almost sixty years later. Here is how it works, how to read the three zones, and where the model misses the mark.
The short answer
- Safe
- Above 2.9
- Grey zone
- 1.23 to 2.9
- Distress
- Below 1.23
What the Z-score measures
The Z-score is not an accounting figure but a statistical model. Altman looked for the combination of ratios that most sharply separated bankrupt companies from healthy ones in the years before bankruptcy. Each ratio was given a weight according to how much it contributes.
There are several versions. The original from 1968 was designed for listed manufacturing companies and uses the market value of the shares. Belgian SMEs have no share price, so Jaarrekening.be uses the later version for private companies, which takes the book value of equity. An even later variant drops the turnover ratio for companies outside manufacturing.
The formula
| Ratio | Calculation | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| X1 | Working capital / balance sheet total | 0.717 | Liquidity: is anything left after short-term debt? |
| X2 | Equity / balance sheet total | 0.847 | The buffer built up |
| X3 | Operating profit (EBIT) / balance sheet total | 3.107 | Return on assets, the heaviest weight |
| X4 | Equity / total debt | 0.420 | How much loss the company can absorb before creditors are hit |
| X5 | Turnover / balance sheet total | 0.998 | How hard the assets work |
Two adjustments for Belgian annual accounts. For X2, Altman used retained earnings, an item the Belgian balance sheet does not show separately; Jaarrekening.be therefore takes total equity. And X5 requires turnover, which is only mandatory in the full format. If turnover is missing, X5 counts as zero on Jaarrekening.be and the score comes out lower.
Read also Micro, abbreviated or full format, which annual accounts do you file?The three zones
| Z-score | Zone | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Above 2.9 | Safe zone | The profile resembles that of healthy companies |
| 1.23 to 2.9 | Grey zone | Undecided. Look at the trend and the other signals |
| Below 1.23 | Distress zone | The profile resembles that of companies that went bankrupt |
The model was built on American manufacturing companies from decades ago. On European SMEs it is less sharp, and a score in the distress zone is not a prediction that this company will go bankrupt. It does remain one of the most useful simple measures, especially if you follow its trend over a few years.
Calculating the Z-score yourself
-
Take seven figures from the annual accounts
Balance sheet total (20/58), current assets (29/58), amounts payable within one year (42/48), equity (10/15), total debt (17/49), operating profit (9901) and turnover (70). -
Calculate the five ratios
Working capital is current assets minus short-term debt. Divide working capital, equity, operating profit and turnover by the balance sheet total, and equity by total debt. -
Multiply and add up
Each ratio times its weight, and the five results together. Or let the Z-score tool do it: it also shows the contribution of each ratio separately.
Example with a building materials wholesaler
| Item | Code | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Balance sheet total | 20/58 | €2,000,000 |
| Current assets | 29/58 | €1,200,000 |
| Amounts payable within one year | 42/48 | €900,000 |
| Equity | 10/15 | €600,000 |
| Total debt | 17/49 | €1,400,000 |
| Operating profit (EBIT) | 9901 | €120,000 |
| Turnover | 70 | €3,000,000 |
- X1: (1,200,000 - 900,000) / 2,000,000 = 0.15. Times 0.717 = 0.11
- X2: 600,000 / 2,000,000 = 0.30. Times 0.847 = 0.25
- X3: 120,000 / 2,000,000 = 0.06. Times 3.107 = 0.19
- X4: 600,000 / 1,400,000 = 0.43. Times 0.420 = 0.18
- X5: 3,000,000 / 2,000,000 = 1.50. Times 0.998 = 1.50
Together Z = 2.23: grey zone. No alarm, but no reason for unlimited credit either. Note how heavily turnover weighs: without X5 the score would be 0.73. Had this wholesaler filed an abbreviated format without turnover, it would have landed in the distress zone with exactly the same balance sheet. That is the model's biggest weakness for Belgian SMEs.
Where the model goes wrong
- Holding companies and management companies. Lots of financial assets, little or no turnover: X5 is almost zero and the score ends up in the distress zone while nothing is wrong.
- Property companies. A large balance sheet total with buildings pushes down every ratio. The score is low, the collateral is real.
- Annual accounts without turnover. Seven out of ten Belgian annual accounts use the micro format, which does not show turnover. For those companies, follow the trend of the score, not its level.
- Young growth companies. A loss-making scale-up with lots of cash scores badly on X2 and X3, while a recent funding round actually shows confidence.
Conversely, a company with a good Z-score can still fail because of something that appears in no ratio: the loss of one large customer, a dispute with the tax authorities or a director who leaves. So always combine the score with the signals that are not on the balance sheet.
Read also Predicting bankruptcy, 5 warning signs you can check for freeZ-score or Health score?
Jaarrekening.be shows both, and they measure different things. The Health score from 1 to 5 weighs solvency, liquidity and profitability over the last three financial years, with the most weight on the most recent year. If turnover is missing, it uses gross margin, so it also works for micro annual accounts. The Z-score looks at one financial year and includes turnover and operating profit. You find it in the company's risk analysis, which is part of Pro.
The strongest signal is the combination: a falling Health score and a Z-score that slides from the grey zone into the distress zone, at a company with real turnover and stock. Then you had better limit your outstanding invoices, or deliver against an advance payment.