Risk & bankruptcy 8 min read

Director liability in a Belgian bankruptcy

When is a director personally liable in a Belgian bankruptcy? The legal grounds, the caps and what you can do yourself as a creditor.

Jaarrekening.be

A customer goes bankrupt, your invoice stays open and meanwhile the managing director is driving a new car. The obvious question: can I go after them personally? Usually not, because the company is your debtor. But Belgian law has a number of cases in which a director pays out of their own pocket. This article covers which ones, who brings the claim and what you can do yourself as a creditor.

The short answer

In a bankruptcy the company remains the debtor. A director only becomes personally liable when the enterprise court decides so, for instance for a manifestly gross fault that contributed to the bankruptcy (art. XX.225 CEL), for carrying on a business with no prospect of survival (art. XX.227 CEL) and for unpaid payroll withholding tax, VAT or social security contributions. These claims are usually brought by the trustee. What the trustee recovers goes to all creditors together.
Debtor
The company
Who claims
Usually the trustee
Cap
EUR 125,000 to 12 million

The company is the debtor

A Belgian BV or NV has its own assets, separate from those of its directors and shareholders. That is the whole point of a company. If it goes bankrupt, the trustee shares out what it still owns among the creditors. Whatever is not paid stays unpaid, as a rule. That the director is doing well privately changes nothing.

Personal liability is the exception, and a court has to establish it. A director of a bankrupt company is not under suspicion because the company failed. They can, however, be liable for what they did or failed to do in the run-up.

When a director is personally liable

Ground Article Who claims Can a creditor act alone?
Manifestly gross fault XX.225 CEL Trustee or a creditor who suffered loss After demand to the trustee
Wrongful trading XX.227 CEL Trustee only No
Social security contributions XX.226 CEL Social security office (RSZ/ONSS) or trustee No
Payroll withholding tax and VAT Art. 51 Tax Recovery Code The tax authorities No
Manifestly inadequate starting equity 5:16 CAC (BV), 7:18 CAC (NV) Interested parties, in practice often the trustee In principle yes
Alarm bell not rung 5:153 CAC (BV), 7:228 CAC (NV) Third parties who suffered loss, or the trustee In principle yes

All of these claims cover current and former directors, managing directors and day-to-day managers, and also anyone who actually ran the company without holding the title. A director who resigned shortly before the bankruptcy is not automatically off the hook.

Manifestly gross fault that contributed to the bankruptcy

If the debts exceed the assets, the court can declare directors personally liable for all or part of the shortfall, if a manifestly gross fault on their part contributed to the bankruptcy (art. XX.225 CEL). Serious tax fraud always counts as such a fault. Beyond that, it covers mistakes no normally prudent director would have made. Think of books that were not kept, or a company that ran for years by not paying the tax authorities and social security.

Two limits. This claim does not apply if, over the three financial years before the bankruptcy, the company had an average turnover below EUR 620,000 (excluding VAT) and a balance sheet total of no more than EUR 370,000 at the end of the last financial year. Many small BVs fall below that. And a creditor who suffered loss may only bring the claim themselves if the trustee does not do so within one month of that creditor's formal demand.

Carrying on when bankruptcy was inevitable

Belgian law uses the English term wrongful trading for this (art. XX.227 CEL). A director is liable if they knew or should have known that there was manifestly no reasonable prospect of saving the business and avoiding bankruptcy, and from that moment did not act as a normally prudent and careful director would have. An example: Schrijnwerkerij Claes BV, a joinery, has been making heavy losses for a year, the bank has called in its credit line, and the director keeps ordering timber on credit from suppliers who will never be paid. There is no turnover threshold here, but only the trustee can bring the claim.

Social security contributions after repeated bankruptcies

The social security office or the trustee can hold directors personally and jointly liable for the social security contributions outstanding on the day of the bankruptcy (art. XX.226 CEL). The condition: in the five years before the bankruptcy, the director was involved in at least two other bankruptcies or liquidations in which social security debts went unpaid. The rule targets people who let one company after another go under.

Payroll withholding tax and VAT

If a company does not pay its payroll withholding tax or VAT, the directors in charge of day-to-day management are jointly liable when the failure is due to their fault. This used to be in article 442quater of the Income Tax Code 1992 and article 93undecies C of the VAT Code. Since 2020 it is in article 51 of the Code on the amicable and forced recovery of tax and non-tax claims. With repeated non-payment, fault is presumed: three unpaid debts within a year for a monthly filer, two for a quarterly filer. That presumption does not apply when the non-payment results from financial difficulties that led to judicial reorganisation, bankruptcy or judicial dissolution. This is a claim by the tax authorities, not by you, but it often runs alongside a claim by the trustee.

A company that had too little from the start

If a BV goes bankrupt within three years of incorporation and its starting equity was manifestly inadequate to carry on the planned business normally for at least two years, the founders are jointly liable for the company's obligations, in a proportion set by the court (art. 5:16 CAC). For an NV the same applies to its capital (art. 7:18 CAC). The court then looks at the financial plan the founders had to give the notary; the notary hands it to the court at the request of the supervising judge or the public prosecutor. Note that this targets the founders, not necessarily the current director.

The alarm bell was not rung

When a BV's net assets turn negative, or it is no longer certain it can pay its debts over the next twelve months, the board must call a general meeting within two months (art. 5:153 CAC, for an NV art. 7:228 CAC). If it does not, the loss suffered by third parties is presumed to result from that failure, unless the board proves otherwise. For a supplier who kept delivering after that point, this is a strong argument. In a bankruptcy, the trustee often uses it to show the board knew how bad things were.

Read also Alarm bell procedure in a Belgian BV, NV or CV: when and how

The most a director pays

The Companies and Associations Code caps director liability at an amount that depends on the size of the legal entity (art. 2:57 CAC). The cap applies to ordinary director liability and to wrongful trading, for all directors together and per event.

Legal entity, average over the last three financial years Cap
Turnover below EUR 350,000 and balance sheet total up to EUR 175,000 EUR 125,000
Turnover below EUR 700,000 and balance sheet total up to EUR 350,000 EUR 250,000
No more than one of: turnover EUR 9 million, balance sheet total EUR 4.5 million EUR 1 million
Larger, but below EUR 50 million turnover and EUR 43 million balance sheet total EUR 3 million
From EUR 50 million turnover or EUR 43 million balance sheet total, and public interest entities EUR 12 million

The turnover and balance sheet thresholds are indexed; the caps themselves are not. The exceptions matter more to you. The cap does not apply to a minor fault that recurs habitually rather than by accident, to serious fault, to fraudulent intent or intent to cause harm, nor to liability for payroll withholding tax, VAT and social security contributions. A manifestly gross fault falls outside the cap by definition.

What you do as a creditor

  1. File your claim

    Via RegSol, within the deadline set in the judgment. Only creditors with an accepted claim share in the distribution, including in what the trustee later recovers from a director.
  2. Tell the trustee what you know

    Orders placed while the director knew they could not be paid, promises made by email, a new company with the same customers. The trustee knows the file from the inside, but not your conversations. Put it in writing, with documents.
  3. Send the trustee a formal demand if nothing happens

    For a manifestly gross fault you can formally demand that the trustee bring the claim. If the trustee does not do so within a month, you may bring it yourself (art. XX.225, § 3 CEL). Expect legal fees; they are reimbursed if the trustee joins the case or if the claim benefits the estate.
  4. Look at the director

    Which other companies do they sit on today? Are any of those in trouble? A string of bankruptcies is an argument for the trustee, and a reason for you to be careful with their next company.
  5. Check for a director ban

    Current bans are listed in the Central Register of Director Bans. You search it on Just-on-web with an eID or itsme, for a person by first name, surname and date of birth, for a company by enterprise number. You only see whether a ban is in force and from when to when, and you may only search if you have a serious reason.
The money does not go to you alone. Whatever the court orders a director to pay goes into the estate and is shared among all creditors, after the costs of the bankruptcy (art. XX.225, § 5 and XX.227, § 3 CEL). Even if you did the work. So weigh the cost of proceedings against what will be left per creditor.

Asking for a director ban yourself

The enterprise court can bar a bankrupt director from running a business or managing a company for up to ten years, when a manifestly gross fault contributed to the bankruptcy (art. XX.229 CEL). If the director did not cooperate with the trustee, a three-year ban can follow. The request can come from the public prosecutor, the trustee or a creditor who was not paid in the bankruptcy (art. XX.230 CEL). It earns you nothing, but it protects the next supplier.

Looking up the director on Jaarrekening.be

Look up the bankrupt company by name or enterprise number and open the Directors tab. You see who is listed as a director in the latest annual accounts, with a link to their person page (free account). That page shows the companies where the person is a director today, each with its legal status, figures and Health score. With Pro you see who was a director in each set of annual accounts, so you also see who left shortly before the bankruptcy.

Former mandates in companies that have already closed are not on the person page. You find those in the older annual accounts of those companies and in the publications in the Belgian Official Gazette. To follow recent bankruptcies, see the bankruptcies page, by province, and for the directors of newly founded companies, the list of new directors.

Read also Find a director, who runs a Belgian company and where else they sit

Summary

In a bankruptcy your debtor is the company, not the director. A director only pays personally if the court finds a manifestly gross fault, wrongful trading, an ignored alarm bell or manifestly inadequate starting equity, or if the tax authorities or social security office pursue them. The trustee usually runs those proceedings, and the proceeds go to all creditors. Your part: file your claim on time, inform the trustee and look at the director before you deal with their next company. This article is general information; for your own case, ask a lawyer for advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is a director personally liable when their Belgian BV goes bankrupt?

No, not automatically. The BV is the debtor, not the director. Personal liability only follows when a court finds fault, such as a manifestly gross fault that contributed to the bankruptcy or carrying on a business with no prospect of survival, or in the specific cases for social security contributions, payroll withholding tax and VAT.

Can I, as a supplier, sue the director myself?

Sometimes. For a manifestly gross fault (art. XX.225 CEL), a creditor who suffered loss can bring the claim if the trustee does not do so within one month of that creditor's formal demand. The wrongful trading claim (art. XX.227 CEL) can only be brought by the trustee. Whatever the court awards is shared among all creditors.

What is the most a liable director has to pay?

For ordinary director liability and for wrongful trading, the cap ranges from EUR 125,000 for the smallest companies to EUR 12 million for the largest (art. 2:57 CAC). The cap falls away for serious fault, fraudulent intent or repeated minor faults, and does not apply to liability for payroll withholding tax, VAT and social security contributions.

Can a bankrupt director start a new company straight away?

Yes, unless a court has banned them. The enterprise court can impose a director ban of up to ten years when a manifestly gross fault contributed to the bankruptcy. An unpaid creditor can also ask for such a ban. Current bans are listed in the Central Register of Director Bans, which you search via Just-on-web.

How do I see which other companies a director sits on?

In CBE Public Search you search by company, in the Functions section. On Jaarrekening.be the Directors tab of a company shows who is listed in the latest annual accounts, with a link to the person page and that person's other current mandates.

Sources

  1. Belgian Code of Economic Law, Book XX: art. XX.225 (manifestly gross fault), XX.226 (social security contributions), XX.227 (wrongful trading), XX.228 (competent court), XX.229 and XX.230 (director ban) (French text) www.ejustice.just.fgov.be
  2. Belgian Companies and Associations Code: art. 2:56 and 2:57 (liability and caps), 5:16 and 7:18 (founders), 5:153 and 7:228 (alarm bell) (French text) www.ejustice.just.fgov.be
  3. Code on the amicable and forced recovery of tax and non-tax claims, art. 51 (payroll withholding tax and VAT) (French text) www.ejustice.just.fgov.be
  4. RegSol, Central Solvency Register www.regsol.be
  5. FPS Justice, Just-on-web (Central Register of Director Bans) justonweb.be

See who is behind a customer

Look up a company and see its directors, their other mandates and the legal status of those companies.

All insights